Mapping conflict of interests: scoping review

A scoping review of the literature to identify all known ties between the medical product industry and the parties and activities in the healthcare ecosystem.


Originally published on 11/03/2021 in BMJ

The range and interrelationships of company ties across the healthcare ecosystem are incompletely described.

The medical product industry maintains an extensive network of ties across the healthcare ecosystem. Most studies of conflict of interests related to pharmaceutical, medical device, and biotechnology companies have focused on one party (eg: prescribers, organizations) or activity (eg: research, education, clinical care) in the healthcare ecosystem.

Researchers at the Drug Pricing Lab created a map through a scoping review of the literature and expert input to show the network of medical product industry ties across all parties and activities in the healthcare ecosystem. The map was derived through synthesis of 538 articles from 37 different countries and is available as an interactive tool on our website.

The map also shows that this network of ties is often unregulated and non-transparent. Enhanced oversight and transparency are needed to shield patient care from commercial influence and to preserve public trust in healthcare.


Key Takeaways

The medical product industry maintains an extensive network of financial and non-financial ties with all major healthcare parties and activities.

This network seems to be mostly unregulated and opaque.

It is therefore up to other key parties, including the healthcare profession and policy makers, to effectively manage commercial influence, protect patient safety, and ensure public trust.

“Physicians, researchers, and the institutions that carry out medical research and education, provide patient care, and develop practice guidelines do not act in isolation but, rather, as part of complex intersecting systems.” Institute of Medicine

Research & Insights

We conduct non-partisan, independent research, and make our work accessible and informative to policymakers and the general audience alike. Browse our featured research or explore our work by article type.

Copay Assistance: The Epipen Example
What happens when a patient uses a copay coupon?
Drug Pricing Lab 06/06/2017
Evaluating Industry’s Drug Pricing Claims
A closer look at three of PhRMA’s most cited talking points.
Drug Pricing Lab 11/18/2021
Mapping conflict of interests: scoping review
A scoping review of the literature to identify all known ties between the medical product industry and the parties and activities in the healthcare ecosystem.
Drug Pricing Lab 11/03/2021
Production Plus Profit Pricing (P-quad) FAQ
What A Waste! The National Academy Of Medicine’s Report On…
Why Congress should not follow the National Academy of Science, Engineering, and Medicine’s recommendation to remove the JW modifier.
Health Affairs Blog 07/09/2021
Medicare Must Study Unproven, Expensive Alzheimer’s Drug
Medicare cannot indiscriminately cover the cost of Aduhelm for the treatment of Alzheimer's disease without first evaluating whether it truly works.
Bloomberg Opinion 06/15/2021
Value-Based Management of Specialty Drugs: Practical Considerations and Implications for…
Not all approaches are suited to meeting policy makers and health plans’ goals of managing specialty drugs based on their value. Researchers conducted a qualitative study with Blue Cross Blue Shield plans interested in implementing value-based specialty pharmacy management to observe the plans’ objectives, strategies, and factors influencing their ability to execute on these strategies.
AJMC 05/13/2021
Instead of debating 'first-shot' vs 'set-aside' vaccine approaches, hospitals' study…
Hospitals could start studies of their own employees to answer important questions, including whether the first-shot approach has downsides when compared to the set-aside strategy.
STAT 01/04/2021
After 4 Years of Trump, Medicare and Medicaid Badly Need…
Many promising ideas won't work as expected, and that's all the more reason for CMS to evaluate how medical care is delivered to its patients.
NYTimes 12/01/2020
Trump's Drug-Pricing Ideas Would Cost Taxpayers a Bundle
Meanwhile, pharmaceutical companies would stand to make a lot more money.
Bloomberg Opinion 09/29/2020
We can't tackle the pandemic without figuring out which Covid-19…
There may be several Covid-19 vaccines by winter, but there will also need to be a study comparing the viruses to one another as part of rolling out widespread vaccination.
STAT 09/24/2020
CMS's Proposed Medicaid Best Price Loophole for Value-Based Purchasing of…
The administration has proposed a loophole in the Medicaid Best Price rules that would dismiss linking the drug's effectiveness to its price.
HA Blog 07/06/2020

Featured News

See All News
Drug Pricing Lab 12/17/2020

Industry Payments Affect What Drugs Physicians Prescribe

In the US, physicians accept a substantial amount of money in gifts and funding from pharmaceutical drug companies, totaling $2.18 billion in just 2018. Evidence shows industry payments are positively associated with physician prescribing behavior. This effect, particularly with the prescription of opioids, runs counter to patients' best interest and physicians' given oath to protect them.
Read Article

Conflicts of Interest Tool

Conflicts of Interest Map

Stay up to date on our work and news